Ann Arbor’s Independent Community Policing Oversight Commission Faces Conflict with Police Chief

. July 6, 2020.
police commission
Stock photo courtesy of Rosemary Ketchum.

The Independent Community Policing Oversight Commission member’s display frustration with the city of Ann Arbor’s lack of effort to include citizen oversight into legislation.

Ann Arbor’s Independent Community Policing Oversight Commission (ICPOC) is not privy to police officers’ identities when reviewing an incident. Yet the committee fights to uphold their responsibility to the public in a meeting Wednesday evening. 

Officers are labeled by numbers in complaints that are reviewed by the ICPOC. According to Michigan’s Collective Bargaining Agreement (CBA) officer’s names are withheld from the commission and are referred to as ‘Officer #1, Officer #2,’ etc. for privacy concerns. This prevents the committee from tracking any specific officers to repeated offenses. Chair of the commission, Lisa Jackson, explained to council members that the commission is not requesting that officers’ names be released.

“It is not our expectation that we need to release those names to the public, but the public needs to have confidence that, as an independent review body, we have looked at those complaints,” said Jackson. “When we see 20 officers come across our desk we don’t know if it’s 20 different officers or one officer 20 times.”

Ann Arbor Chief of Police, Michael Cox, defends the department’s current procedure for reviewing complaints by claiming that history is not relevant when reviewing an isolated incident.

“If the person is a frequent flyer or it’s the first time that we’ve looked into it, it should be the same as far as what we find. Media attention is on something totally different — they might attach onto the fact that someone has been investigated before, but as far as the investigation itself, it [officer’s identity] shouldn’t have any impact.” said Cox. 

However, another rule included in the CBA states that the previous 24 months of an officer’s history can be taken into account. Commission member Jude Walton asserted that if two years of history is considered relevant, then the CBA does support reviewing a portion of an officer’s record. 

Jackson stated that ICPOC has not been included in any recent policy changes, and the city has ignored the valuable oversight they provide. 

“If this Collective Bargaining Agreement goes forward as is, we’ll continue for three years to have no input from any citizen oversight body. It will not have taken into account any of the last three months of reflection on citizen oversight in the United States of America,” said Jackson. 

The committee has also recommended that the duration of evaluation be extended from two years to seven. Chief Cox believes that an extension of that size is excessive.

“You want people to have the ability to rehabilitate themselves if they make mistakes along the way,” said Cox. 

ICPOC board members expressed their frustration with the lack of cooperation from the city. Jackson cites seeking out support from resources outside of Ann Arbor to advocate for citizen’s review. Board member Sarah Burch questioned the board’s purpose if the city displays minimal interest in the ICPOC’s perspective. 

“The commission’s purpose is to work along with the police. We might as well not exist if we are not able to actively participate,” said Burch. 

City Council will review the requests of ICPOC at their meeting on Monday, July 6. If the requests are not approved, the commission will continue negotiations until procedures change. 

Although the ICPOC is facing obstacles with city legislation, Jackson and the commission is committed to being an accountable public service for the people.

“The problem in Ann Arbor is that we don’t have established processes for us to be included in these conversations,” said Jackson. “The public — locally certainly, and even nationally — are understanding the value of civilian oversight. But institutions are much slower to change, and we all have some expectation of change now. We feel the urgency from the people.”The next City Council Meeting will take place on Monday, July 6 starting at 7pm. More information can be found on the cities calendar here.


Louis Picasso & The Gallery Exhibit ‘The Burning Canvas’ (Live Album)

Louis Picasso and The Gallery have made a grand gesture with their newly released live album. Several gestures, really.  First and foremost, the Ypsi-based alternative-rap ensemble wanted to give something to their fans. They wanted to give something to music-lovers everywhere, truth be told. Because it’s been a rough year, and we need something that’s

The Hard Road and the Lessons Learned: Shawn Butzin’s Adventures Continue

New single, Indigo Sky, is the first of a series of new music. Shawn Butzin reveres songwriting as a kind of expedition, and fulfillment is the arrival. In this case, the finished song. Fittingly, a recent release was titled Adventures; also, several of the songs on his debut album came to fruition while he was

Michigan and State Theaters to Reopen Friday, October 9

The Michigan and State theaters are reopening this week! This is what you need to know about safety protocols as the theaters are reopening and what’s playing.

Bountiful Harvest: Growing Hope Launches Auction Fundraiser to Benefit their Mission

Local chefs and food personalities are lending their expertise to help Growing Hope raise money to keep residents of Washtenaw County fed. Here’s how to join the auction!